The Water Lot Inn at the Fairmont Southhampton Hotel in Nassau Bermuda
Il Mulino in New York City (interestingly enough the second time was just OK)
Felidia in New York City
Topolobampo in Chicago (happily, the second time was equally as good)
Le Florimond in Paris
I've had lots of other really amazing meals at places like The Inn at Little Washington (Little Washington, VA) , Le Bec Fin (Philadelphia), Po (NYC), Boulevard (San Francisco), Nola (New Orleans), Le Coq au Vin (Orlando) and many more. Somehow the particular meals I had at the five I listed rise to the top. How about you?